THEN1: This 1877 north-looking panorama of Seattle’s waterfront features the Windward (center left) on tide flats where it still rests underground today. At upper right, the impressive Pike Street wharf and coal bunker can be seen, near today’s Aquarium. Photographers Henry and Louis Peterson likely captured this view from the back porch of their Cherry Street studio. (Paul Dorpat collection)NOW1: From atop a 10-story garage, much of the waterfront is obscured by tall buildings. State ferries can be seen departing from Colman Dock. The Windward’s location is near the center of the photo. (Jean Sherrard)
Published in The Seattle Times on-line on Sept. 26, 2024
and in Pacific NW Magazine of the printed Times on Sept. 29, 2024
A buried maritime treasure sleeps beneath Seattle streets
by Jean Sherrard
It’s safe to assume that Seattle is the only American city with a nearly forgotten sailing ship buried below its downtown streets.
5:45 p.m. on Dec. 30, 1876, the Windward ran aground at Whidbey Island’s Useless Bay, having mistaken a beach fire for the Admiralty Point Lighthouse during what a keeper called “a perfect gale.”
The Windward’s original bell was donated to the Museum of History & Industry in 1982 by Isabel Colman Pierce, granddaughter of James Colman. Its “sweet sound” called generations of Colmans to supper. (courtesy MOHAI)
Hauling 525,000 board feet of lumber from James Colman’s mill on Seattle’s waterfront, the 650-ton bark was bound for San Francisco, helmed by Capt. A.E. Williams with a crew of 15.
Williams, wrote the Puget Sound Dispatch, returned to Seattle by canoe on New Year’s Day with grim news. The Windward, he reported, “is now lying, dismasted and on her beam ends … about a mile from the beach.” Owned by Colman (known for Colman Dock) and partners, the vessel was only partially insured, though most of its cargo was saved.
Originally built in 1853 in Bath, Maine, the Windward regularly rounded Cape Horn until 1872, when it became a “coaster” plying the Seattle-to-San Francisco route. In this zoomed-in detail from an 1878 Peterson Bros. panorama, original deck cabins can be seen. (Courtesy Ron Edge)
Declared a complete loss, the Windward was towed back to Seattle and deposited on tide flats.
For years to come, its distinctive oak hull photobombed panoramic portraits of Seattle’s waterfront. Colman used it for storage and allegedly maintained a ‘pied-à-mer’ in its deck cabins.
One day, teenaged Charles Kinnear, whose father, George, donated Queen Anne Hill’s Kinnear Park to Seattle, swam to the hulk at low tide. “We boys tore copper from her bottom and dived from her decks,” he later recalled. Though the tall masts had long disappeared, “they provided,” Kinnear said, “many souvenir canes” for local dandies.
Standing at the intersection of Marion and Western, maritime historians Michael Mjelde and Stephen Edwin Lundgren indicate the Windward’s likely location. (Jean Sherrard)
On occasion, the derelict hosted festivity. On July 2, 1877, the Daily Intelligencer suggested, “Walking a greased pole, for a ten dollar prize, off the old bark Windward will be very amusing.”
In the late 1880s, with the filling in of then-Railroad Avenue (today’s Alaskan Way), the vessel was buried intact. Debris from the 1889 Great Seattle Fire extended the fill.
Every few decades since then, Seattle historians remembered the Windward’s underground presence.
Clarence Bagley in 1901 reminded readers of the “dismantled craft … [that] still lies in the mud” on Western Avenue “with her stern projecting into Marion Street.”
In 1949, Seattle Times columnist C.T. Conover re-imagined it under the same streets “throbbing with modern traffic, its bow pointed … toward the harbor as if eager to be once again at the scenes of its former glory.”
And in 1982, Paul Dorpat whimsically suggested that the Windward “no longer sways with the tides … [but] permanently jaywalks below Western Avenue.”
Today, aiming time’s arrow once again, we encourage waterfront visitors to take a dreamy breath and envision Seattle’s buried maritime treasure beneath their feet.
WEB EXTRAS
To view our narrated 360 video of this column, please click here!
Quick thanks to Bill Kintner who sent a note that indicates San Francisco also has ships buried under streets.
THEN: A portion of a cheering crowd of 40,000 greets the unveiling of the First World Flight monument during the Sept. 28, 1924, landing of the round-the-world achievement at then-Sand Point airfield. (Frank Jacobs, Seattle Star, National Air and Space Museum)NOW: In a rare moment of traffic calm, standing in front of the First World Flight monument at the intersection of Northeast 74th Street and Sand Point Way are centennial organizers (from left): Elisa Law, executive director, Friends of Magnuson Park, and celebration co-chairs Ken Sparks (holding 1924 Douglas biplane model) and Frank Goodell. (Jean Sherrard)
Published in The Seattle Times online on Sept. 19, 2024
and in Pacific NW Magazine of the printed Times on Sept. 22, 2024
Success of First World Flight in 1924 drew monumental fanfare
By Clay Eals
Its base covers just 6 square feet of ground. Its alluring feature, a pair of eagle wings, hovers 15 feet up, far above eye-level. And while the wings are elegant, they don’t instantly signify aviation.
Those factors may help explain why few Seattleites probably have appreciated or even glimpsed the monument at Magnuson Park (formerly Sand Point Naval Air Station) that celebrates a Seattle-to-Seattle achievement dubbed the First World Flight.
THEN: Heralding the return of the First World Flight is this portion of the Sept. 29, 1924, front page of The Seattle Times. (Seattle Times online archive)
The feat was truly monumental — a cadre of pilots in open-cockpit biplanes enduring storms, snow, crashes and rescues while touching 22 countries in a 175-day, 74-stop sojourn, as recounted in “Now & Then” last spring. It began with a Sand Point take-off on April 6, 1924, and culminated at the same airfield when 40,000 cheered the odyssey’s final landing 100 years ago this Saturday, Sept. 28.
It’s a centennial worth celebrating, and a doozy of a bash is planned.
THEN: This aerial shows a portion of present-day Magnuson Park, with four red dots pinpointing the locations of the monument over the years, based on research by volunteer Lee Corbin. (Courtesy Friends of Magnuson Park)
But first, the monument. Created by Seattle sculptor Victor Alonzo Lewis and unveiled upon the round-the-world flyers’ return, the marker had three other locations near the airfield from 1924 to 1938. Today, it anchors a narrow median at the park entrance, hemmed in by signs and a small tree.
At Northeast 74th Street, with drivers heeding traffic signs and a signal and passing beneath the park’s weathered brick overpass or entering busy Sand Point Way, small wonder that few gaze skyward to view the granite-and-bronze marker’s backlit wings. Sadly, it’s more a faceless near-irrelevance instead of the tribute it’s meant to be.
NOW: Displaying promotional signage at the Magnuson Park entry kiosk are First World Flight centennial organizers (from left): Elisa Law, executive director, Friends of Magnuson Park, FriendsofMagnusonPark.org, and celebration co-chairs Ken Sparks (holding a 1924 Douglas biplane model) and Frank Goodell. (Clay Eals)
Elisa Law and a contingent of aviation buffs respect the monument but also look past it for different ways to herald the First World Flight. Friends of Magnuson Park, directed by Law, aims to convert an onsite empty ex-gas station to a visitor center. The Friends also want to otherwise elevate the stature of the 1924 feat. As Law says, “We should have it written at Sea-Tac Airport: Home of the First World Flight.”
Centennial festivity, however, comes first.
The Museum of Flight plans displays and programs Sept. 26, 27 and 29, and the Swedish Club hosts a Sept. 27 dinner, all in support of the big day: Sept. 28. That’s when from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. Magnuson Park is the site of a vintage aircraft flyover, a Navy band performance, pilot storytelling, historic film screenings, an exhibit, plus a rare chance to experience the adjacent National Oceanic & Atmospheric Administration’s outdoor Seattle Sound Garden. Details are at FirstWorldFlightCentennial.org.
The day honors a marvel that started and ended here. If you go, look for the monument!
Big thanks to Elisa Law and Lee Corbin for their invaluable help with this installment!
To see Clay Eals’ 360-degree video of the “Now” prospect and compare it with the “Then” photos, and to hear this column read aloud by Clay, check out our Seattle Now & Then 360 version of the column.
Retired KOMO-TV stalwart Dave DePartee displays a prized copy of the Seattle Post-Intelligencer front page announcing the return of the First World Flight. (Clay Eals)THEN: Leona Nathalie Fengler, “Miss Seattle” of 1926, driving a 1926 or 1927 Peerless, poses with the monument. (Courtesy Friends of Magnuson Park)THEN: In his Eastlake Avenue studio in August 1924, sculptor Victor Alonzo Lewis works on a clay model for the top of the monument, which was dedicated Sept. 28, 1924. (Seattle Times online archive)Gov. Jay Inslee’s proclamation of Sept. 28, 2024 as First Flight Centennial Celebration Day.The Friends of Magnuson Park board of directors in August 2023: (from left) Lynn Ferguson, vice-president;, Ken Sparks, president; Joseph Diehl, treasurer; and board members Ruth Fruland, John Evans, Cynthia Mejia-Giudici, Frank Goodell, Larry Duckert, Jorgen Bader, and Pat Hooks-Bass, secretary. Not pictured: Carl Sargent and Larry Gill. (Courtesy of Friends of Magnuson Park)April 25, 1924, Seattle Times, p8.Aug. 1, 1924, Seattle Times, p1.Aug. 1, 1924, Seattle Times, p11.Aug. 2, 1924, Seattle Post-Intelligencer, p2.Aug. 3, 1924, Seattle Post-Intelligencer, p3.June 3, 1924, Seattle Times, p11.Aug. 13, 1924, Seattle Times, p4.Sept. 12, 1924, Seattle Post-Intelligencer, p11.Sept. 28, 1924, Seattle Times, p10.Sept. 29, 1924, Seattle Times, p1.Sept. 30, 1924, Seattle Times, p1.Sept. 30, 1924, Seattle Times, p20.Oct. 9, 1924, Seattle Times, p5.April 7, 1925, Seattle Times, p24.Sept. 27, 1974, Seattle Post-Intelligencer, p23.Aug. 19, 2004, Seattle Post-Intelligencer, p18.Aug. 19, 2004, Seattle Post-Intelligencer, p19.
THEN: Stu Moldrem’s Space Needle-based prelude for the 1974 National Governors’ Conference graced the Seattle Post-Intelligencer front page on the gathering’s first day, June 2. Then-Gov. Dan Evans is at bottom. At top are then-Govs. Reubin Askew, Florida; Dale Bumpers, Arkansas; Ronald Reagan, California; Wendell Ford, Kentucky; Jimmy Carter, Georgia, and Winfield Dunn, Tennessee. On the elevator is then-Massachusetts Sen Edward Kennedy. (David Eskenazi Collection)NOW: Former Washington Gov. and U.S. Sen. Dan Evans repeats the 1974 pose drawn by artist Stu Moldrem. “Now & Then” enlisted Evans’ son, former corporate-communications writer Dan Evans Jr., as our guest photographer to capture his dad for this installment. (Dan Evans Jr.)
Published in The Seattle Times online on Sept. 12, 2024
and in Pacific NW Magazine of the printed Times on Sept. 15, 2024
Presidential puzzle jogged Evans-led governors session in 1974
By Clay Eals
May 18, 1973, Herblock editorial cartoon on Watergate TV hearings.
However unfathomable this year’s presidential marathon may seem, certainly it’s memorable. Oddly enough, that’s how many of us felt a half-century ago, in 1974.
It wasn’t a presidential-election year, but the nation’s top job topped the country’s consciousness. In Congress, 51 days of Watergate hearings had supplied riveting television. By the time of the National Governors Conference, hosted June 2-5, 1974, by then-Gov. Dan Evans in Seattle, impeachment hearings had begun against the scandalized Richard Nixon. The guvs’ hottest speculation focused on who would become the next elected president.
June 2, 1974, Seattle Post-Intelligencer, p1.
Presciently depicting this puzzle on the June 2 Seattle Post-Intelligencer front page, artist Stu Moldrem drew Evans anchoring a Space Needle crowded with political celebs.
On top were six attending governors, including two future presidents: Reubin Askew, Florida; Dale Bumpers, Arkansas; Ronald Reagan, California; Wendell Ford, Kentucky; Jimmy Carter, Georgia, and Winfield Dunn, Tennessee. Riding the Needle’s elevator was Massachusetts Sen. Edward Kennedy, who spoke to the conference in favor of national health insurance and was presumed to top the 1976 Democratic ticket.
June 2, 1974, Seattle Post-Intelligencer, p11.
Conferees fished for salmon in Westport, visited the Longacres horse track and dined black-tie at the Olympic Hotel. A few even stopped by Spokane for the Expo ’74 world’s fair. But they also speechified and swapped presidential predictions. From the KING-TV studio, six governors, including Evans, appeared on NBC’s “Meet the Press,” during which Evans three times cited “this time of national turmoil.”
Two months later, Nixon resigned. A month after that, his successor, VP Gerald Ford, drew scorn for granting him “a full, free and absolute pardon.” Talk about turmoil!
Kennedy, it turned out, didn’t run in 1976. Carter became the Democratic nominee and defeated Republican Ford. Four years later, Republican Reagan defeated Carter.
NOW: Kneeling to photograph his dad is Dan Evans Jr. For more of his work, visit DanEvansJr.Photography. (Clay Eals)
This July 24, Evans repeated his pose in person at the Needle. Just shy of 99 and revered as a liberal Republican and environmental champion, the former three-term governor (Washington’s first) and six-year U.S. senator fondly recalled the 1974 conference.
He also tersely eyed today’s political scene. No fan of re-nominee Donald Trump, he lamented, “There aren’t any Republicans left in Seattle.” Is democracy on the ballot this November? “No. We’ll survive OK.”
THEN2: In December 1968, P-I artist Stu Moldrem inks in a Pilot Profile in advance of the 1969 debut of Seattle’s major-league Pilots baseball team. Moldrem also designed the team’s uniforms and logo. (David Eskenazi Collection)
News artist Moldrem died in 2015 at age 90. For 34 years, he produced countless creations on myriad topics, mostly sports. The P-I labeled them “Sportraits.”
His daughter Lisa Moldrem, of Kirkland, rates his elaborate end-of-year sketches, in which he incorporated hundreds of names of Seattle sports celebs, among his best work. “He knew that people enjoyed it,” she says, “but he always wondered if they would remember it.”
We do!
THEN: Baseball was the theme of an original late-1951 Moldrem names sketch, complete with penciled guidelines. “The more famous you were,” says his daughter, Lisa Moldrem, “the bigger or more centered your name was.” The names of Lisa and her brother typically were slipped into the annual pieces. (David Eskenazi Collection)THEN: For Tommy Harper Day, Aug. 22, 1969, Moldrem depicted the beloved Seattle Pilots base-stealer on the canvas of second base. The base came from now-demolished Sicks Stadium in south Seattle and was presented to Harper. (David Eskenazi Collection)
WEB EXTRAS
Big thanks to Dave Eskenazi, Lisa Moldrem, Genny Boots and especially Dan Evans Sr. and Jr. for their invaluable help with this installment!
To see Clay Eals’ 360-degree video of the “Now” prospect and compare it with the “Then” photos, and to hear this column read aloud by Clay, check out our Seattle Now & Then 360 version of the column.
THEN1: No photograph of the longhouse exists. This colorful painting, which hung above Quinault elder Emmett Oliver’s mantel, was adapted from a fanciful, post-fire sketch by artist Hal Booth. While its height may be exaggerated here (somewhat greater than its actual 12 feet), the cedar structure’s 500- to 900-foot length and 60-foot width had to have been impressive. (Painting by Hal Booth, courtesy Marylin Oliver-Bard)NOW1: Two canoes from the July 28, 2024 Paddle to Puyallup are drawn up onto the banks of Old Man House Park. Its single acre claims 200-plus feet of beach front with Agate Pass Bridge at upper left. Notably, it is the only land given to an Indigenous tribe by Washington state. (Jean Sherrard)
Published in The Seattle Times on-line on Sept. 5, 2024
and in Pacific NW Magazine of the printed Times on Sept. 8, 2024
In Suquamish hearts, long-burned ‘sacred’ longhouse lives on
by Jean Sherrard
Last week, we visited the Suquamish reservation, a vibrant stop on the 35th anniversary of an annual canoe journey that began with 1989’s Paddle to Seattle.
For Suquamish elder Barbara Lawrence, the event bracingly reinvigorates her culture. “Today, my children and grandchildren only know canoe life,” she says. “They assume that making canoes, paddles and cedar hats, and bringing back our songs, dances and languages, is just a normal part of their lives.”
Barbara Lawrence (left), tribal education outreach specialist, sits with fellow Suquamish elder Lorraine Brice during the 2024 Canoe Journey. (Jean Sherrard)
But celebrating gains doesn’t negate almost unfathomable losses that devastated Indigenous peoples.
Lawrence, a tribal education outreach specialist, directed me to the site of a legendary longhouse burned to the ground 154 years ago. Although white settlers called it “Old Man House” from Chinook jargon, its original Lushootseed name has not yet been recovered.
Built around 1800, the vast, cedar-plank structure housed up to 600 people, including Chief Kitsap and his close relation, Chief Seattle. It served as a winter village, hosting weighty rituals and potlatch celebrations.
An 1895 sketch titled “Plan of Old Man House” reveals extensive post and beam construction plus its waterfront location near Agate Passage. Chief Seattle died in the longhouse on June 7, 1866, his passing largely ignored by the town that bore his name. (Public Domain)
The largest construction of its time in the Northwest, its massive cedar posts and beams supported what historian David Buerge has called “the most remarkable structure ever created on Puget Sound.”
Following Lawrence’s directions, I walked a half mile past waterfront homes (with signs asserting that the beach was private property). I discovered a one-acre park given by Washington State Parks to the Suquamish Tribe in 2004. While nothing remains of the original longhouse, this sliver of land chronicles trauma and erasure.
The decades after its construction exposed its inhabitants to explorers and settlers — “the invasion,” Lawrence calls it — along with disease, religion and broken promises.
When she was a young researcher collecting oral histories for the Suquamish Museum, she elicited a story from elder Bernard Adams about the last hours of the longhouse.
In 1870, federal authorities, intent on removing the symbol of communal living, ordered its destruction.
When Chief Seattle’s daughter, Kikisoblu (aka Angeline), living in his namesake town, heard that the longhouse was burning, “she got into a canoe and came over. As it burned down, she was screaming and throwing sand on the cedar posts in a desperate attempt to save anything, crying out, ‘Me Sapa house!’ [my grandfather’s house] over and over again.”
A canoe is carried up the Suquamish boat ramp, named in honor of Charles Lawrence, Barbara’s late father and former tribal chair. (Jean Sherrard)
Defying federal pressures, however, remaining tribal members soon erected a cluster of “little houses … just above and behind where the longhouse had been, as close as they could be to each other.”
While the Suquamish continue to address painful legacies of the past, they are no less committed today to revitalizing community and culture. As Lawrence says, “All the doors are open for us now.”
WEB EXTRAS
Most of the single acre of Old Man House Park is show here.A deep layer of clam shells suggests feasts of yore.As canoes approach and are welcomed to Suquamish land, children play on the beach.