(click to enlarge photos)
Carolyn Marr, the librarian at the Museum of History and Industry (MOHAI) and an authority of the photographer Anders Wilse’s years in Seattle, thinks that this his look east through the entrance to Salmon Bay – from Shilshole Bay – was probably taken in 1900. That was Wilse’s last busy year in Seattle before he returned to Norway. During his few years here Wilse received many commissions from businesses and the City of Seattle to do photographic surveys. But why did he record this bucolic view over a Lawtonwood pasture with seven cows?
It was not long after Wilse recorded this view of the channel that the Army Corps started dredging it in preparation for the ship canal. Throughout the 1890s smaller “lightening ships” hauled cut lumber from the many Ballard mills on Salmon Bay to the schooners anchored in deep water off of Shilshole Bay. No vessels here, however. The channel is near low tide. You can make out the sand bars.
The home of Salmon Bay Charlie, a half-century resident here, can be found to the far right. With irregular roof boards it may be mistaken for part of the shoreline. Charley was one of the principal suppliers of salmon and clams to the resident pioneers on both sides of this channel. Wilse gives us a good look across the tidewaters into a west Ballard that while clear-cut is still sparsely developed. The Bryggers settled and developed that part of Ballard, and the few structures seen there may belong to them.
Librarian Marr finds two other related views in MOHAI’s Wilse collection. One looks in the opposite direction across the channel from Ballard, and the other is a close-up of Salmon Bay Charlie’s cedar-plank home. Marr adds, “Wilse was interested in boats and waterways, as well as Indians.”
One last note: those may be Scheuerman cows. The German immigrant Christian Scheuerman and his native wife Rebecca were Lawtonwood pioneers. Settling here in 1870 they multiplied with 10 children.
Once again guided through the back streets and secret passages of Magnolia, the inestimable Jon Wooton led me to the spot near where Wilse’s ‘Then’ photo had been taken. The following closer shots of the railroad bridge were taken on return trips over the next couple of days.
Anything to add, Paul? A few things now and a few more later in the week with a Salmon Bay Addendum. Here, by near coincidence, is a view of the Great Northern bridge when it was nearly new. Both views look from the north side of the bay. This “then” was photographed by James Turner – unless I am corrected. (Click to enlarge – twice.)
Next – if we may – we will reflect on what changes along this way must have transpired in the mere 60 years between the above the photograph and the one that now follows.
Before there was the Space Needle there was the Kalakala – serving as the principal symbol of Seattle and Puget Sound. The ferry was introduced in 1935 to help locals take their minds of the Great Depression. The Black Ball Line named her after the native Indians’ mythical “flying bird” and advertised her as the “world’s first streamlined ferry.” The publicity worked. Puget Sound’s first streamlined symbol was known from Peoria to Peking.
The Kalakala’s function, however, did not follow its form. It vibrated badly, and was not particularly fast. Its daily wartime work of transporting nearly 5,000 ship workers between Seattle and Bremerton earned it the proletarian title “Workhorse of the Sound.”
The tear-shaped vessel was first sketched by the avant-garde industrial designer Norman Bell Geddes, and so apparently not by a Boeing engineer as is widely believed. Bell Geddes managed to design an auto ferry that did not resemble a steam-powered garage. The Kalakala’s aluminum skin was stretched over the burned-out hull of the San Francisco Bay ferry Peralta, towed north in 1934 for its transmutation.
Here, the Kalakala is on an excursion through the Chittenden Locks on April 24, 1947. Twenty years later, her wings were clipped and she was towed to Kodiak, Alaska, where she was landlocked as a crab-processing plant. (This feature first appeared in Pacific on Nov. 3, 1991, when the magazine was still credited to both the big local pulps then, “The Seattle Times/Seattle Post-Intelligencer.” This explains the timing and hopeful fancy of the remaining copy.)
Ever since, persons of energy and imagination have labored to bring the “flying bird” back to Puget Sound, the waterway for which she was once an international symbol. Most recently this effort has been organized by the Kalakala Foundation.
SALMON BAY CHARLIE
Salmon Bay Charlie and his wife lived in their cedar plank home on the south shore of Magnolia’s Salmon Bay. For half a century Charlie, also known as Siwash Charlie, sold salmon, clams and berries to the first settlers and later to the soldiers at Fort Lawton. Today’s historical view shows Charlie’s house at the turn of the century, taken by the photography firm, Webster and Stevens.
Charlie’s native name was HWelch’teed, and he probably was the last of the Sheel-shol-ashbsh (hence Shilshole) group that centered on this once narrow Shilshole-Salmon Bay inlet to the fresh water interior. (“Sheel-shol-ashbsh” translates to “threading the bead,” which was descriptive of the canoe trip to lakes Union and Washington.) The Shilshole Indians were one of the eight or nine principal tribes who lived in what we now call Greater Seattle. LocaI historian David Buerge has determined that this Salmon Bay site was once the center of a large community whose area extended from Mukilteo to Smith Cove. Here, long before Charlie’s shack was built, three long houses dominated the area. The largest house was big enough for potlatches, the gift-giving ritual ceremony.
The Shilsholes went into a sudden decline a half century before ‘white settlers grabbed their land. Once about 1800 of their numbers were ravished by “a great catastrophe,” most likely an attack by one of the slave-taking, booty-hunting and beheading North Coast tribes. By the time pioneer Henry Smith settled Smith Cove in 1853, the tribe had dwindled to a dozen families at most. By the late 1880s there were only two families left.
Steady white settlement, started in the 1875 when German immigrant Christian Scheurman moved to the area, cleared the timber and married a native woman who had ten children before she died in 1884.
In 1895 Seattle boosters organized to attract a military post to the area and gathered the acreage that is now Fort Lawton-Discovery Park. The part of it that is now Lawton Wood, shown in our contemporary photo, is not part of the military holding because Scheurman withheld it.
Soon after the military moved in next door, this protected enclave was improved with mansions of a few of Seattle’s elite. In 1952 these neighbors – about 30 houses sparingly distributed about a generous 30 acres – organized the Lawton Wood Improvement Club waving the motto “To Beautify and Develop Lawton Wood.” By the time that the last of the Scheurmans, Ruby, moved out in the late 1970s the beautifying had turned more to developing, and the lots got smaller.
Any attempt to, recreate the perspective used in the photo of Charlie’s shack would have put in the bay. During the early part of the 20th century, deep-water dredging by the Army erased the old Indian’s promontory. The excavation revealed the many layers of discarded clam shells that piled up over the centuries of native settlement.
In 2003 I returned to the site to deliver a slide show lecture on Salmon Bay to members of the Magnolia Historical Society. We met in a member’s home that overlapped Charlie’s “property” broadly foot-printed. The new print of Charlie’s above – and his dog – had surfaced from a collection kept by one of the Society members, Russ Langstaff. Here first is the picture, followed by the feature on it that appeared in Pacific, also in 2003.
SALMON BAY CHARLIE’S VISITORS (With some of the news form above used again.)
Later this day – after I have finished writing this – I am attending a benefit for the Magnolia Historical Society (MHS) as they prepare to write and produce a second volume of “Magnolia: Memories & Milestones.” We will be meeting at the home of Betty and Tink Phelps and within whispering (that is, not shouting) distance of where the historical photographer stood who took this week’s “then” photo of three black suits visiting Charlie (or Hwehlchtid) the last of the Duwamish Indians to live on Shilshole Bay. Of course, while I am at the benefit I will photograph the contemporary scene (including some society members) printed here as a “repeat” of the historical photograph.
Magnolian Russ Langstaff found this newest addition to the small store of Salmon (or Shilshole) Bay Charlie photographs while thumbing through the stock of images taken by both his father and uncle early in the 20th Century. However, it took two-time society president Monica Wooton, while searching for photographs to illustrate the MHS’s first book, to identify this scene as one of Charlie, his dog and his home.
While the towering trio are not identified it has occurred to more than one “reader” of the photograph that perhaps these are the agents from the Office of Indian Affairs who removed Charlie from his home to the reservation soon after his wife Madelline died. That was at the time the Ballard (Chittenden) Locks were under construction. One source says 1915 and another 1916 for Charlie’s removal.
Although, of all the historical maps of Shilshole Bay that have been found none mark the site of Charlie and Madelline’s home (city maps were generally made to sell property and not to identify and so perhaps help preserve native homes like Charlie’s), the several surviving photographs of this historical home lead us confidently to the Phelps back yard or at least very near it.
Now and Then Captions together: Until about 1916 when it was burned Salmon Bay Charlie’s home was a landmark fixture on the southwest shore or the Magnolian side of Shilshole Bay. Like the contemporary deck of the Phelps home, this sturdy shack of the last of the Shilshole band of the Duwamish Tribe sat on a promontory or knoll near the foot of what was later developed as Sheridan Street in the Bay Terrace Addition of the Lawtonwood neighborhood. The site was also dredged for a widening of the waterway into the locks.
(Historical view courtesy of Russ Langstaff. I took the “now,” below, myself. Jean’s contributions began in 2004. Will we make a decade together Jean?)
In some now lost time of the 1990s I mounted a large exhibit of Salmon Bay neighborhood pictures in Hirams Restaurant, which overlooked the locks and the bay. I think the name has been changed twice since, and the pictures were removed during a subsequent remodel, and also apparently destroyed – or lost – by the owner. This portrait of Salmon Bay Charlies standing with his goods was included in the exhibit and captioned so . . . “ From his home on Salmon Bay, Salmon Bay Charlie gathered clams and netted salmon for sale or barter with Ballard residents. After the death of Chief Seattle’s daughter Princess Angeline in 1896, Charlie was the community’s best known native. He was especially popular among children to whom he would tell stories of his own youth. This studio portrait was probably marketed as a souvenir. Soon after his wife Madeline died in 1914 or 1915, the elderly Charlie was sent to a reservation by the Office of Indian Affairs. Bill Phillips, Charlie and Madeline’s neighbor and probably a relative as well, soon afterward burned down their home. It was the native’s practice to burn the homes of the dead in order to ritually separate them from earth.”
Before showing the homes of two of Charlies neighbors – those on the south and north sides of Chittenden Locks – we will pause to show a few more salmon.
Follows now two past Pacific features about Salmon Bay Charlie’s neighbors, the Shillestads on the Magnolia side of the locks, first, the the Bryggers on the Ballard side following.
BEFORE the LOCKS, the SHILLESTADS
Ole and Regina Shillestad knew each other in Norway. As students, then married here in Seattle. They raised their four children on the south shore of Salmon Bay beside the site of the future Chittenden Locks. The couple acquired this land in 1876. Four years later they built their home here and planted an orchard of about 30 trees: plum, pear and apple. A sliver of the orchard is evident on the left just behind the fence built above the high-side line.
A skilled Norwegian carpenter, Ole built the home himself as well as that of his neighbors, John and Anna Brygger, who lived just across Salmon Bay. (The Brygger home, which survives as part of the Lock Spot Tavern.) Both homes were ornaments with Shillestad’s hand-cut details.
In 1898 King County bought a portion of the Shillestad property in its campaign to lure the federal government to build locks at the site. The family home was moved a short distance during the canal’s construction, and when the waters were at last raised in 1916 behind the Lock’s new spillway, the Shillestads picked the fruit of their orchard from a rowboat (perhaps the one seen here.)
After the family moved to lower Queen Anne, the old home was rented often to caretakers of what remained of the old Shillestad family property. Commercial development of the south shore began shortly after World War II, and for a time June Shillestad and her brother operated the Sealth Souvenir Store and Lunch Counter alongside the spillway dam. The family home survived until the mid-1970s, when it was replaced by the apartments that now look down on Chittenden Locks.
THE BRYGGERS of BALLARD by Salmon Bay
Anna and John Brygger moved from their log cabin in 1887 into this, their first finished home. The lumber for it was logged from their homestead on the north bank of Salmon Bay, towed to Seattle for milling and then rafted back for construction. John died the following year, but the much younger Anna lived until 1940.
Before his death at age 65, Brygger had his successes. He was one of the first to try commercial fishing and canning on Puget Sound. In the summer of 1876, the Intelligencer (a predecessor of the Post-Intelligencer) reported that “Mr. John Brygger, a Norwegian capitalist and fisherman, has purchased a site on Salmon Bay about six miles north of the city, where he has already commenced the business of catching and canning salmon.” His skill was such that he was able to open a bank in his native Norway with earnings. This banking confidence he passed on to his son, Albert, who later became president of Seattle’s Peoples National Bank.
The Brygger home was built on a knoll a short distance north of Salmon Bay – and the future Chittenden Locks – near the present intersection of Market Street and 30th Avenue Northwest. In 1948 the site was condemned to allow the extension of Market Street west from 29th Avenue Northwest. Frank Canovi, Lock Spot Tavern owner, bought the Brygger home and moved the oldest part of it less than 100 yards south of the original site to his popular beer parlor.
[We hope later this week to put up another blogaddendum, this one of the buildings of the Chittenden locks – if time is kind, this week. And sometimes between then and now, we also hope to proof the above. Now it is time for another visit to the kingdom of slumber that Bill Burden has so honestly named the “nightybears” or “nighty bears.”]
10 thoughts on “Seattle Now & Then: 'Threading the Bead' Between Magnolia and Ballard”
Mr. Dorpat, you have no idea how fortuitous this article is for me! I am a Board Member of the Kitsap County Historical Society and am spearheading the reprinting of ‘Kitsap County: A History’ published in 1977. In the section on North Kitsap (Book II) we have two photos labeled as Chief Seattle’ home and Princess Angeline’s home. The reference for the photos is ‘Souvenir of Chief Seattle and Princess Angeline’, published in 1909 by Laura Buchanan. Neither photo looked right to me so I tried to track down the Buchanan book, but was unsuccessful. I did, however, come across a Skagit Journal review of Coll Thrush’s ‘Native Seattle: Histories from the Crossing-Over Place’. In it was a photo labeled as an indian home in the area of the Chittenden Locks, razed in 1914. It was only slightly different from the photo we had labeled as ‘Chief Seattle’s home’, obviously taken at a slightly different time.
In reading your article, and looking at the photos, it would appear that both our photos are the same building(from the north and the south), that is Salmon Bay Charlie’s house!
Now my question is – where did Laura Buchanan get her information??? Do you know anything about her? I found that the Seattle Public Library has a copy of the book in Special Collections (10th floor). It has no name of a publisher and no information about the author. I’m curious about her because she goes into great detail about Angeline being abducted by a French-Canadian trapper who took her inland at the Canadian border area, where she lived for 12 years (and mistreated her). After his death by stabbing she returned to her people with her daughter (I’m assuming that’s ‘Lizzie’). I have never heard that story before, or any mention of the possibility. I’m inclined to ignore it, especially now that the photos have been shown to be mis-identified.
If you have any further infirmation I would love to have it – not for publication but for my own peace of mind during this editing nightmare!
I can be reached at this email address at weekends or by phone during the week at 206-842-7343.
I trying to figure out if this Salmon Bay Charlie could be a descendant of the Salmon Bay Curley, mentioned in several histories as the one who warned settlers in Seattle before the 1856 atack. A relative, cousin, possibly the same person! Have to be in his 90’s I guess to be the same person — but does anyone know?
In historical books they like to change up the names and as I myself am a descendent of Salmon Bay Curley. I am very positive this is Chief Salmon Bay Curley.
I just came across your message from Jan 2016, in reply to my question from 2011.
I have been doing some research on the Scheuerman family that Dorpat mentions here, and would be interested in finding out more about your info on this.
My email is Cjnorth@outlook.com
Think Charlie may have been the same as warm beach Charlie? Ive been researching. Enjoying it. Looking for what i saw years ago my grandparents dads sisters and brother’s living I though at the bottom of the bluff or across from shilshoe bay or golden gardens. We were all from Ballard greenwood Northgate area. I played on i5 as it was being built. And walked across it before with my grandma at her last house across I5 from northgate. But their all buried in Ballard Crown Hill i believe. Never to be forgotten. So weird my grandson has gravitated back to Ballard. And my sons an avid Fisherman. Thanks to all the memories online. I even remember hereing about playland but wasnt alive before its demise. And the ferris wheel at woodland park. The rides at woodland park and kiddy pool. 1958 or 59 because im in the stroller.
Thank you, thank you for all of this beautifully thoughtful and helpful information about this little corner of Seattle. I would love to share some of this info in some marketing material I am creating for a house I am selling in “Lands End” next week. It makes it so much more meaningful and I’m sure it will for the future owners as well.